Review: Liga Privada Único Serie Dirty Rat


One of the most anticipated cigars of the year is the first in Drew Estate’s Único Serie. Dubbed the Dirty Rat, or Rata Sucia in Spanish, is not all that new. Drew Estate began handing out preproduction samples as early as October of 2009I first reviewed a preproduction sample of the Dirty Rat way back in December of 2009.

The idea behind this blend was to produce a Corona-sized cigar with made with seven different tobaccos — five different fillers + the wrapper and binder. Unfortunately, it costs almost the same to produce this blend in a Corona as it does to make it in a Double Corona size and it needs to be made in the Corona to keep the flavor and strength profile.

The wrapper used on the Dirty Rat is grown in the Connecticut River Valley. And while it resembles Broadleaf, which is used on Liga Privada No. 9, it is actually the same Havana-seed wrapper that is used on the Liga Privada T52. The binder is Brazilian, and the filler is a mix of Nicaraguan and Honduran tobaccos.

As mentioned earlier, the Dirty Rat is the first release in the Ünico Serie, which will basically be a group of specific cigar sizes (vitolas) produced in the Drew Estate factory using blends that are different from the standard Liga Privada No. 9 or the Liga Privada T52 blends. Drew Estate President Steve Saka said it thusly:

At this point, we have made 200 or more Liga Privada blends…There are probably nine or 10 of them so far that are exceptional….They’re cigars that work as a particular size, such as a lancero or Corona, with the blend being unique to that particular vitola. The Dirty Rat is a great example of this, so we have decided to introduce this as the first cigar in the Ünico line.

Saka has also credited Nicholas Melillo for creating the Dirty Rat telling SMOKE:

Nicholas Melillo created the “Dirty Rat” blend using the five-fillers-in-a-Corona techniques he developed on his own and it was simply delicious. We have been making them since early 2009 in small batches for own consumption and to share with friends. We have been discussing the possibility of releasing this product into the marketplace, the problem is it costs so much to make this Corona due to the difficulty of the bunch.

_______________________________________________________________________

The Dirty Rats will come in boxes of 12, priced at $12 for each cigar. Interestingly, these will NOT be a limited release, but will be produced “in small batches as long as there is a demand for them in the market.” The boxes for the Dirty Rats look like this.

Liga Privada Único Serie Dirty Rat 1.png

Liga Privada Único Serie Dirty Rat 2.png

Liga Privada Único Serie Dirty Rat 3.png

Liga Privada Único Serie Dirty Rat 4.png

Liga Privada Único Serie Dirty Rat 5.png

Liga Privada Único Serie Dirty Rat 6.png

Liga Privada Único Serie Dirty Rat 7.png

Liga Privada Único Serie Dirty Rat 8.png

_______________________________________________________________________

But enough of that, let’s get down to business, shall we?

Liga Privada Único Serie Dirty Rat 9.png

  • Cigar Reviewed: Liga Privada Único Serie  Dirty Rat
  • Country of Origin: Nicaragua
  • Factory: La Gran Fabrica Drew Estate
  • Wrapper: Connecticut River Valley Stalk Cut & Cured Sun Grown Habano
  • Binder: Plantation Grown Brazilian Mata Fina
  • Filler: Nicaraguan & Honduras
  • Size: 5 Inches
  • Ring Gauge: 44
  • Vitola: Corona
  • MSRP: $12.00 (Boxes of 12, $144.00)
  • Release Date: August 2011
  • Number of Cigars Released: Regular Release
  • Number of Cigars Smoked for Review: 4

The cigar itself is extremely attractive. It has quite a bit of oil on it and the darkish slightly reddish brown wrapper is quite rough to the touch. I love the pigtail as well, as it adds just a little bit of something extra to the cap. However, there are no major prominent veins. The cigar is very firm when squeezed and the wrapper smells of sweet earth, cinnamon and something that reminded me of spicy apples. Just a great smell coming from the cigar.

Interestingly, the wrapper on the preproduction and the regular release are not quite the same color, as the preproduction (left) is just a tad darker in tone than the regular production stick, although this is EASILY within normal production samples.

Liga Privada Único Serie Dirty Rat 10.png

_______________________________________________________________________

The first third started out with an immediate and somewhat overwhelming pepper and spice combo that would have shocked me if I had not been ready for it). However, the intensity faded after about ten puffs and continued to fade until it was just a great background note. Main flavors in the first third were a spicy earth, dark chocolate and cedar. A wonderful start to a cigar and the burn was great as well.

Liga Privada Único Serie Dirty Rat 11.png

The flavors shifted abruptly around the start of the second third, with the profile becoming quite a bit more creamy in nature, but the spice that was present also picked up a bit. I started tasting some cinnamon and sweet cedar as well. The strength is slowly building and I can feel it starting to affect me.

Liga Privada Único Serie Dirty Rat 12.png

In the final third, the flavors that were present all seemed to coalesce into a wonderful combination that was literally so great I could do nothing but sit back and enjoy it. Sweet, spicy and creamy all at the same time with different flavors floating in and out the whole time. The strength definitely saved its punch for last, as it got VERY strong right at the end, as well as a bit bitter — nothing too bad (and nothing a little time down will not cure easily), but it was there. Of course, if I was not trying to smoke it to the nub, I probably would not have noticed.

Liga Privada Único Serie Dirty Rat 13.png

_______________________________________________________________________

Final Notes:

  • Again, I have to mention the amazing construction, burn and draw of this cigar and really, every Liga Privada I have smoked. I don’t know what they are doing over at La Gran Fabrica, but whatever it is, it works. PERFECT describes it, but barely.
  • As with the preproduction samples, this is still a very strong cigar. However, I don’t think it was quite as strong as I remember the preproduction samples being. This could be due to any number of things (i.e. extra time age wise on the blend), but it is noticeably not as strong to me.
  • This thing produces smoke like a freight train. Quite a bit more smoke then the smaller vitola would suggest and very spicy as well.
  • This is the definition of a great stick to age. Over time, the strength, spice, pepper and flavors will all combine (even more) into an even more amazing smoke. Count on it.
  • The finish was still excellent, as I expected.
  • Compared to the preproduction sticks I smoked, the regular production cigars burned a bit quicker. My average time for the regular production sticks was about one hour and 25 minutes compared to about one hour and 40 minutes for the preproductions.

_______________________________________________________________________

The Bottom Line: I ended my original Preproduction Review of the Dirty Rat literally BEGGING Steve Saka to produce them. And thank the Lord, my wish has been granted. I contended then that if the blend stayed the same, that it would be one of the Top Cigars of the Year, and I still think that. All of the great things about the preproduction samples I smoked have been retained in the regular production sticks: the refined strength, the complexity in the blend and the astounding construction. In fact, the only thing I can find fault with is the price, which, as Saka mentioned many times while testing this blend, is a bit expensive for the vitola you are buying. But honestly, this cigar is so good, I will find a way to forget about that every time I smoke one.

Final Score: 95

67 comments
Josh
Josh

Just had my first one and wow, look forward to meeting Steve Saka next weekend at an event here in Dallas.

Jack
Jack

GREAT review, as usual. I especially appreciate the follow-up and your take on consistency and finally giving it a grade/rating. Thanks, again!

-Jack

Ryan
Ryan

Hey donutboy 2000, where did you get your box? Local B&M? I got the last 7 at my local, but I'm hearing they're not getting anymore anytime soon. Grabbing 2 boxes for myself and possibly 2 more for friends the second I see them.

donutboy2000
donutboy2000

I just got a box so please take me out of the contest.

Mayor
Mayor

Good review..have to check these out

ron
ron

cant wait to try these. great review.

benzopyrene
benzopyrene

okay i wish to try one! :-) You've convinced me.

omar
omar

Hi:
Can anyone please tell me where i can buy this beauty?

Garrett
Garrett

I love the corona format. You usually don't see these in limited edition smokes. Fits well in the hand, and usually the flavors seem more prominent. Would love to try.

Logan
Logan

Gotta get my hands on one of these!

Sully
Sully

Great review...I'm new to the site, but I eagerly await every new stick! Lookin' forward to more...

Sully

Steve Saka
Steve Saka

Wow!

Btw, the price just went up to $14 a stick... <snicker>

Austin_Smoker
Austin_Smoker

Brooks, I have room on my humidor. Go ahead and send one, or 10, this way. ;)

GREAT review!

Foe
Foe

I'm gonna add a box of these to my wish list. $12 is indeed a budget buster; but in boxes o' ten, they're do-able. BTW, I received my PDR BotL contest stick this past weekend. Many thanks! Lookin' forward to smokin' it! Keep Smokin' dem Stogies for us, eh?! =)

Badmotorshayman
Badmotorshayman

Excellent review, Brooks. I smoked one two weeks ago and was shocked with how much better it was than LP #9 or the Flying Pig.

donutboy2000
donutboy2000

How do these compare to the Flying Pigs?

George B
George B

Great review! Cant wait to try!

njstone
njstone

Great review and pics, Brooks!

A "95" seems about right to me! I personally think the original #9 Flying Pig and T-52 Toro are solid 94s as well. The LPs are just amazing cigars.

I agree with Steve that this is a cigar that the majority of casual smokers won't be able to handle. For for the "hardcore" cigar smokers, I think this is a real treat. For those of us who enjoy a cigar (or more) daily, it's rare to find something that truly blows us away in ALL the categories: Flavor, Body, and Strength. But I agree that the Dirty Rat does just that. I call it "Extra-Full" on all three counts.

I plan to get 2 boxes sometime before Christmas. One to age (for a couple years at least), one to smoke :)

Ant
Ant

Great to see the cigar's creator leaving a comment on here.

Where can you get these from if you live abroad (Australia for instance)?

Ryan
Ryan

Managed to snag the last 7 of these from my local B&M this evening on the way home from work. Could not wait to light one up, so me and a buddy got down on some. Wow! Fantastic! Both of us concur, one of the best sticks we've ever had, and we've had and have some premo sticks! And remember this is on no rest for this cigar. Grabbing the next 2 boxes I see without a doubt. So worth it. These things are going to be amazing next summer after a long winters rest. Barely even snipped the triple cap and the draw was nothing short of perfect. Pre-light draw hits you with pepper and sweetness immediately. The volume of smoke is fantastic. Burn is impeccable, requiring no touchups almost down to the nub. We both smoked these down so far we were burning our fingers. Not because it was burning hot, but because we were touching the burn line! This thing didn't seem to burn hot even when it was puffed a lot. The first third opens up with spice and a lingering sweetness. Second third things mellow out the flavors toned down significantly. I began to detect hints of chocolate and a slight bitterness in here, too. Final third, spice picks up, but not as much as the first third, and the sweetness comes back up. Flavor profile changes a lot. Just a top-notch smoke. If you're thinking this is too expensive, just go pick up one stick. This is something everyone should smoke.

Peter D
Peter D

I have had an every growing interest in the Dirty Rat since it started making the rounds at Drew Events earlier this year. Your review has just brought my interest into the realm of obsession. THANKS!

Kris
Kris

Sounds wonderful!!!!!!

Christopher
Christopher

My long wait for a cigar that puts de lime in de coconut may finally be over.

nic olson
nic olson

great review as always, you have got me excited again for this stick!

Cateacher
Cateacher

Well done Brooks. Need to get my hands on a couple of these.

Cass
Cass

If a T-52 is good and a LP 9 is better I can only imagine how amazing these must be!

James
James

Thanks for another great review! With that price it is very nice that it comes in a smaller box.

bgscfd
bgscfd

Enjoyed the review.

greg
greg

i haven't tried any of the LP's yet, this review has def. piqued my interest.

Zé do Charuto
Zé do Charuto

Sounds like one to seek out.. Also out of my price range, but maybe I'll luck out here!

ChrisM
ChrisM

I was able to grab a box earlier this month and now have only 2 sticks left! I love this smoke!

Keith1911
Keith1911

Great review! I look forward to trying one I win here or one I pick up at my local shop.

Paul P
Paul P

Thanks for the review...great lookin stick!

aj
aj

Thanks for the review! Can't wait to try one of these! It looks wonderful!

bigbwalls
bigbwalls

Love the review, Brooks. I've had an almost identical experience with the two Dirty Rats I've smoked now. I love the spice and pepper the cigar gives off.

While it's a great cigar, I think I prefer the flavors and balance of the T52 more.

Luca
Luca

Love the redux reviews :)

JoshK
JoshK

No price is too steep price if I win one ;-)

Frank
Frank

Great review as always. I've never seen any Liga Privadas at my local B&M, hopefully they will carry these...if not, online it is, wouldn't want to miss this one.

jpm
jpm

I won a pig from you last winter, now I want a rat!

FastTX
FastTX

Just waiting for the local B&M to get some. Great review, as always.

Ryan
Ryan

Can anyone who has grabbed some online comment on where to find them? I've only found one website that offers them, and they are currently out of stock. Thinking 2 boxes need to be ordered whenever I find them!

HabanoHam
HabanoHam

Nice Review Brooks! I'm very anxious to try one of these especially after reading the pre production and current blend are the same.

CbusDave
CbusDave

Great review! Loved the prerelease, would love to see how these stack up

TriMarkC
TriMarkC

From both your reviews, this sounds like a fantastic cigar, and I'm a Drew Estate geek already! I think I'll take your advice and put a couple away - it sounds like the strength is more than I can handle currently, but I'm working my way "upstream".

Dbell
Dbell

Come on local B&M, hurry up with recieving these.

Mike M.
Mike M.

Oh yeah, sorry Brooks. Great review as usual.

Mike M.
Mike M.

Geez Steve, if you're smoking 2 of these a day they sure will be limited! Save some for us. Had the pre production and loved it, keep 'em coming.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] a few limited editions have popped up in the form of Flying Pigs (reviewed here and here), Dirty Rat, L40 and Feral Flying Pig have been added to the Ünico Serie line and a new line Ünico Fuerte [...]

  2. [...] was still not ready for primetime due to a couple of different factors. First, the demand for the Dirty Rat was already insane, and they did not want to exacerbate that issue. Second, there were apparently [...]

  3. [...] The Connecticut River Valley Habano wrapper is not only used on Ratzilla and its smaller brother Ünico Serie Dirty Rat, but also on Drew Estate’s regular Liga Privada T-52 [...]

  4. [...] might have been upset over the use of the word “dirty” is probably Drew Estate with its Dirty Rat and Dirt [...]