Review: Punch Diademas Extra (ER Italia 2009)
For those of you that don’t know, in 2008, the Punch Diademas Extra (Edición Regional Italia), part of the Regional Edition Series out of Cuba was scheduled to be released. Unfortunately, there were significant delays, reportedly due to the fact that the first batch of gold foil used the wrap the cigar was lost, the second batch was of unusable quality, and finally, the last batch did not actually arrive until late 2009, and you could not actually buy the cigars until early 2010 in most places. Interestingly, there have been some boxes with box codes from 2008 that have been found. What this means is that most likely, the cigars were already aged up to two years by the time they reached the open market.
The Vitola, officially a “Diademas Extra”, is the re-release of an older regular production size that was discontinued in 1980 and replaced with the slightly longer and smaller RG Diademas Extra (2) (9.2 inches x 55 compared to 9.3 inches x 47), which was also discontinued in 1988.
The Punch Diademas Extra (ER Italia) was a fairly limited release, with only 1,020 boxes of 10 cigars (10,200 cigars total) rolled for the worldwide market by the exclusive distributer, Diadema. Here some photos of the boxes they come in (photos courtsy of CubanCigarWebsite.com)…


But enough of that, let’s get down to business, shall we?

- Cigar Reviewed: Punch Diademas Extra (Edición Regional Italia 2009)
- Country of Origin: Cuba
- Factory: Miguel Fernández Roig
- Wrapper: Cuba
- Binder: Cuba
- Filler: Cuba
- Size: 9 3/16 Inches
- Ring Gauge: 55
- Vitola: Giant Perfecto
- MSRP: $25.00 (Boxes of 10; $250.00)
- Date Released: 2009 (But not available until early 2010)
- Number of Cigars Released: 1,020 Boxes of 10 Cigars (10,200 Total Cigars)
- Number of Cigars Smoked for Review: 2
I have to say, the first time I saw one of these cigars in person, it was extremely impressive. It is a physically ginormous stick, with a very interesting shape; certainly not something you see every day, and I don’t know of a non-cuban cigar that comes close to the look. Couple that with the shiny gold foil that covers the entire length of the smoke, and you have a cigar that you will not forget after seeing it. Although the foil did feel a bit flimsy, I found it pretty cool that the two bands were on the outside of the foil as well. And, speaking of the bands, the second band, which is blue with a crown front and center and officially called the “S1″ band, is not used on any other cigar other then this one.
As I mentioned, this is a large stick (I actually wrote “Huge Fucking Cigar” in my notes), and I love the gold foil presentation. When the foil is taken off, I was stuck with a VERY strong scent of barnyard, hay, pepper and chocolate, what I would call a uniquely Cuban combination. The wrapper is a light to medium brown color, and is quite rough. I would call it “rustic” feeling and it is slightly spongy when squeezed.
The first third started off nicely enough, albeit mildly, with just a tad bit of pepper on the tounge that quickly faded into flavors of chocolate, leather and tobacco.

The second third had was still quite mild, but stared to turn just a bit creamy as well, with a cedar flavor appearing, along with the same leather notes from the first third.

The last third was pretty much more of the same. The pepper never made return, which is a pity, and while the cigar was quite creamy in nature, there just was not that much to it; just the same leather, cedar and tobacco flavors that were present in the first two thirds of the stick.

Final Notes:
- Despite the huge size, there was very little smoke coming from this cigar.
- This cigar has the dubious distinction of being the largest (overall) cigar I have ever smoked (that I can remember right off the bat). Larger then the Opus X “A” (9.2 x 47), the “El Padrino” (7.5 x 55) and the Hemingway Masterpiece (9 x 52) just to name a few.
- As with almost all perfecto vitolas, the burn and draw on this cigar was pretty bad until right after the “bulb” but then evened out nicely.
- There have always been rumors that almost every Edición Regional coming out of Cuba are rolled with the exact same tobacco into different vitolas. I won’t go that far, yet, but it is awfully interesting that the profiles seem to be eerily similar, even across different brands.
- The Final Smoking Time was 2 Hour 45 Minutes, but it felt like 3 days.
The Bottom Line: This cigar was kinda like a marriage. It starts out great, but lasts way too long and at the end of it, you just want to chunk the whole thing (if my wife is reading, I am just kidding about the marriage part…but NOT about the cigar part). It got boring about halfway through, then just got MORE boring until it was literally a waste of time to continue, although in the interest of being fair, I had to finish it, sadly, it really was not worth the effort. Just another monotonous monstrosity in a sea of mediocrity that is the Cuban Regional Release series of cigars.
Final Score: 75
















Brooks,
i highly encourage you to smoke one of these again...if you still have any. i smoked one two days ago...complete bliss. a huge leap forward from early ignition.
-ben (two guys one stick)
The presentation of the cigar is really exceptional...if you go for all the bling. The unique band is also a unique color...seems like there are not to many blue cigar bands out there...
Too bad about the cigar... but nice alliteration
Awesome review --- and SO SAD on the 'gar. They just *look* so... great! And I generally love Punch.
Great looking cigar! Too bad it wasn't more enjoyable.
Have a couple of singles I will let sit based on this review, hopefully they find them selves in a couple of years
Bart
Agreed. Very nice presentation indeed! Wish it would have been a better smoke though!
Love the presentation of the cigar but sounds like that is the only highlight of this smoke! Thanks for the reveiw Brooks
I like the S1 band quite a bit. Too bad about the rest of it.
LOL, loved the review. I have a couple of these in the humi and i haven't smoked them literally because of the size. I don't know what it is but i had a feeling these weren't going to deliver. too bad because it's such a beautiful stick. Great review!