Review: Quesada q d’etat Molotov


In December of 2011, SAG Imports/Quesada announced a new project that would be the company’s first cigar solely created at Quesada’s new factory and an effort to raise awareness for cigar rights. Manuel “Manolo” Quesada’s company would create the q d’etat line as a way to protest increased restrictions on cigar smoking and higher taxes for the industry. The first size was aptly named, Molotov.

 

_______________________________________________________________________

 

The December 8th press release reads:

December 8, 2011 — The Q d’etat line represents a symbolic revolt against the unfair taxation practices and mistreatment of the premium cigar industry.  The brand is intended to create awareness of the dangers increased government regulation and taxation will produce, specifically the FDA’s desire to regulate premium cigars. There will be three sizes, released at different dates, of 1,000 ten-count boxes.  Each box will contain a form to register for membership in Cigar Rights of America.

The first of the three sizes is a figurado called the “Molotov” and will be released in January.  We chose the name because the term was first coined by the Finns in reference to the cocktail bombs they utilized to fight against Communist oppression from the Soviet Union during the Winter War in 1939.  When the Soviet foreign minister Vyacheslav Molotov falsely claimed Soviet planes were dropping bread baskets and not bombs over Finland, the Finns began to refer to the bombs as Molotov Bread Baskets and responded by naming their own improvised incendiary devices Molotov cocktails, joking that they needed a drink to enjoy with the food.

We chose Dec 8th, 2011 to issue this press release because it is the 20th anniversary of the dissolution of the Soviet Union.  Shaped like a Molotov cocktail measuring 5 x 38/58/44, this cigar is a great size for the thousands of us who will have to smoke outside in the freezing cold this winter because of draconian smoking bans that prevent us from enjoying a cigar indoors at our favorite bars, restaurants, and, often times, even cigar shops.

Wrapper, binder, filler are all Dominican.  MSRP for the Molotov will be $7.95

Quesada shipped the Molotov to retailers on February 8, 2012 and the cigars went on sale this past Thursday.

 

_______________________________________________________________________

 

Here’s what the box of the Molotov looks like:

Quesada q detat Molotov Box 1

Quesada q detat Molotov Box 2

Quesada q detat Molotov Box 3

 

_______________________________________________________________________

 

The artwork on the inside lid of the box shows off the inspiration:

Quesada q detat Molotov Box 4

 

_______________________________________________________________________

 

At the top of each box is a card to sign up for Cigar Rights of America:

Quesada q detat Molotov Box 5

 

_______________________________________________________________________

 

And the particulars. Quesada q detat Molotov 1

  • Cigar Reviewed: Quesada q d’etat Molotov
  • Country of Origin: Dominican Republic
  • Factory: The Quesada Factory
  • Wrapper: Dominican Republic
  • Binder: Dominican Republic
  • Filler: Dominican Republic
  • Size: 5 Inches
  • Ring Gauge: 38 x 58 x 44
  • Vitola: Perfecto
  • Est. Price: $7.95 (Boxes of 10, $79.50)
  • Release Date: February 9, 2012
  • Number of Cigars Released: 1,000 Boxes of 10 Cigars (10,000 Total Cigars)*
  • Number of Cigars Smoked For Review: 3

*There will be 1,000 boxes of each vitola, making the release a total of 30,000 cigars.

 

The Molotov has one of the weirdest shapes I’ve ever seen in the world of cigars. Even beyond the unclosed cap at the top, it’s just weird. The good news is that it’s a pretty clean roll and a solidly packed cigar. From the dark Dominican wrapper I get a fairly pungent and acidic aroma, whereas the foot is more earth and chocolate. Cold draw doesn’t help the normalization process as the Quesada gives off a very sweet orange aroma, some underlying spice, vanilla and harshness at medium-full. Unfortunately, aroma from the wrapper is easily recognizable while taking a cold draw. That encourages the lighting of the cigar, which produces a pretty typical toasty note from the Dominican puro.

 

_______________________________________________________________________

 

It starts with cedar, earth, bits of leather and fruit on the medium finish. There’s not much pepper at the beginning of the first third, but that quickly changes. Once it settles down the profile is a lot of layered cedar, pepper on the throat and some earthy notes. There’s little in terms of flavors and there’s not an overwhelming amount of complexity, but the Molotov is in your face. Unfortunately, the burn struggles to stay straight pretty early on, nothing major, but obviously a concern given my lack of experience with the shape.
Quesada q detat Molotov 2
The second third sees the pepper temporarily amp up before dying down. Overall, the cedar gets a bit sweeter and fruits on the retrohale help the process, but the flavor profile really doesn’t change much with the only other addition being a hint of dry cocoa. The strength is still medium, which isn’t much of a change from the first third, but the Molotov definitely tones itself down a bit in terms of being in your face.
Quesada q detat Molotov 3
By the time the final third comes around, I’m a bit mystified at how slow the Molotov burns, but nonetheless, interested as to if the flavors are going to change. At this point, the cigar will only narrow in terms of size, almost looking like an ice cream cone. In the end, there’s a bit of changes, but it’s still cedar at the core, some black pepper and a bit of fruits. With an inch left, the cigar definitely begins to go, and I let the Molotov go out.
Quesada q detat Molotov 4

 

_______________________________________________________________________

 

Final Notes:
  • Molotov is the first cigar for SAG Imports/Quesada that was created at the new factory, but Nat Sherman’s Timeless was actually the first cigar released that had never been made at MATASA.
  • The foot reminds me a bit of my beloved Montecristo Compay 95 Aniversario Salomones II.
  • Not only are the bands difficult to photograph, questionable looking and not the cleanest in terms of application, but they also are glued together, which is interesting.
  • The next q d’etat is supposed to be announced at ProCigar 2012, which is also the formal opening of the Quesada’s new factory.
  • Construction was okay. It never went out, but the burn was hardly straight. Ash held on, draw was a bit open. Perhaps most importantly, all three Quesada Molotovs I’ve smoked have been nearly identical in their construction.
  • Strength is medium plus at the strongest point, although body is rather full.
  • All three burned at nearly the same rate, very very slow. Final Smoking Time was 1 Hour 45 Minutes.
  • If you would like to purchase some, site sponsor Atlantic Cigar has them for sale here.

 

_______________________________________________________________________

 

The Bottom Line: I previously have proclaimed that 2012 was going to be a rather important year for Quesada. While the Molotov is definitely is a much different direction than the products that have come from Quesada, I’m not necessarily the largest fan of it. The in your face nature of the flavor profile is interesting, but for me, it doesn’t work. Still, this is a cigar that many will enjoy and I imagine most will enjoy more than me. Yet my largest gripe has to do with the burn rate, which for me is just too slow. A good cigar, but one that makes me want to try the upcoming two sizes of q d’etat more than returning to another Molotov.




Final Score: 83

28 comments
nwbonick
nwbonick

Great review Charlie. I'm still trying to hunt down some Espanas, but if I run across one of these, I'll have to give it a try.

PopAndLockness
PopAndLockness

As everyone else is saying, the shape is really interesting. Can't wait to give this a shot.

bwgan
bwgan

Only ever had one Quesada, the Espana which I thought was amazing...sounds like I'm not going to be chomping at the bit for a US Botl to seek one out for me

BruceLong
BruceLong

Great shape on that cigar. Thanks for the review.

SH341
SH341

Great review, love the concept of the cigar.

SeanCon
SeanCon

thanks for the contest and review

agsansoo
agsansoo

Great review. Can't wait to try a few of these. I thoroughly enjoy all Quesada cigars I've smoked so far. I hope this one is just as good. I understand why Quesada choose this shape. Just because you can, doesn't always mean you should. ;)

chas
chas

Looks good, love to try it!

adavis1138
adavis1138

Looks like a good stick, and your description sounded higher than an 83. Hey, you smoked it, not me. Nice review.

Charlie Minato
Charlie Minato moderator

@adavis1138 I think this gets at the halfwheel scores. I'd buy another one without much issue. That being said, I'd still like to try the other two sizes before I do. 83 doesn't make this a bad cigar whatsoever.

adavis1138
adavis1138

I suppose the extreme high end (and occasional crap) that you guys get to smoke makes an 83 seem different than what I would personally consider an 83.

Love the site, keep it up!

RightAJ
RightAJ

Love the shape, and the blend sounds interesting. I'd like to give one a trty

Gavin
Gavin

Quesada has been turning out some first class cigars lately. I'm definitely on the lookout for these.

JamesHale
JamesHale

Interesting looking stick. I saw these at an event but bought some espanas instead.

HabanoHam
HabanoHam

Nice Review! I was excited when I heard about these , they seem pretty different. Hopefully a little age helps bring the score up.

Chris McCann
Chris McCann

Interesting-looking stick. Thanks for the review!

maxx
maxx

I will stay with the Espana.

LennyM
LennyM

I love the concept of the cigar! Thanks for the review.

RandyJ
RandyJ

Do any of your site sponsors have them in stock?

Charlie Minato
Charlie Minato moderator

@RandyJ Atlantic has them. Not on the website yet and they are closed today. We'll put a link up tomorrow once they get on their site. Quesada says the other four all didn't order any and since they are sold out (to retailers), I doubt any of the others would get any.

Justin Bonnette
Justin Bonnette

Nice review. The size had me intrigued but your review makes me think I should locate a single as opposed to a 5er.

Mr Penny
Mr Penny

The box artwork looks awesome, quesada products have always impressed me, too bad this one didn't live up to its looks.

SpittyE
SpittyE

Interesting review. I've been excited about this release, but the review dampens that a bit.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] involvement in cigar regulation. The first release in the line was the Molotov, which Charlie reviewed here. Soon after the Molotov’s release the announcement was made about a Memorial Day release of the [...]

  2. [...] Quesada Q d’etat Molotov (5 x 38/58/44) — 1,000 Boxes of 10 Cigars (10,000 Total Cigars) — February 2012 [...]