Review: Tatuaje Barclay Rex 100th Anniversary (Prerelease)

If you are a Tatuaje fan, you will be excited to know that Pete Johnson has honored a Cigar shop in New York City called Barclay Rex by making a cigar to celebrate their 100th Anniversary in business. 100 years in the cigar business…That’s a beautiful thing. Here is a little info on Barclay Rex that you may not have known…..

“In 1910, Vincent Nastri, a pipe maker from Salerno Italy, made a very bold move by taking his craft one step further. He ventured into the world of tobacco and almost a century later, his vision still thrives in downtown Manhattan. The store was opened on Barclay and Church Street and taking the cue “a dog is man’s best friend”, Nastri, with his Great Dane Rex in tow, set out to create Barclay Rex.”

100 years later there are now 3 locations of Barclay Rex all of which are in New York City….

www.BarclayRex.com

75 Broad St # 1, New York – (212) 962-3355

570 Lexington Ave # B, New York – (212) 888-1015

70 E 42nd St, New York – (212) 692-9680

The Shop on Broad street and the shop on East 42nd street are owned to this very day by the Nastri Family . The Shop on Lexington is part owned by the Nastri Family and part owned as well as first and foremost operated by a wonderful gentleman named Billy Rella. I only have experience in dealing with Billy’s store on Lexington, and i have to say between himself and an awesome guy named Adam Panarella you will not find a better operated cigar store. If you have any questions they will gladly help you out and they have one of the nicest and highly maintained humidors you will ever see. Billy and Adam are your “salt of the earth” type of people and once you speak with them you will see that they are completely invested in your needs. They also have a great relationship with a lot of the top cigar makers as you will often see Barclay Rex gets a lot of special cigars other places won’t. They were one of the first if not the very first shop in New York City to carry Tatuaje, thus one of the reasons Pete is showing his appreciation by doing this cigar for their Anniversary.

According to Adam Panarella from Barclay Rex, they had a major hand in the development of the blend and Pete Johnson has been quoted as saying “it’s the pork tenderloins big brother” (which we reviewed here).

The Box presentation is exceptional. The cigars come in a custom cabinet of 25 with the shop on Lexington (Billy’s place) getting 100 boxes and the other 95 boxes being split up between the other two locations. Here are some shots of the box itself…

Tatuaje Barclay Rex 100th Anniversary 1.png

Tatuaje Barclay Rex 100th Anniversary 2.png

Tatuaje Barclay Rex 100th Anniversary 3.png

Honestly, I am not the biggest fan of the choice of band, and at this point that would be the only negative for me. (Although I must admit it is growing on me.) It sports a RC or T110 retro colored band with gold trim and a La Vérité style front with the words “Barclay Rex 100th I just don’t know if I like the elegant gold mixed with the casual retro colored band. Interestingly, this release is also the first time the “Exclusive Series” band has been used… this same band will be used on all of the future Exclusive releases (i.e. single store releases) with just the name in the middle of the band changing…According to Pete, they are a play on old Cuban retro bands used for diplomats…

Tatuaje Barclay Rex 100th Anniversary 4.png

Let’s get to the review!

Tatuaje Barclay Rex 100th Anniversary 5.png

  • Cigar Reviewed: Tatuaje Barclay Rex 100th Anniversary
  • Country of Origen: Nicaragua
  • Factory: My Father Cigars S.A.
  • Wrapper: Connecticut Broadleaf
  • Binder: Nicaragua
  • Filler: Nicaragua
  • Size: 6 Inches
  • Ring Gauge: 52
  • Vitola: Toro
  • MSRP: $10.00 (Boxes of 25, $250.00)
  • Date Released: November 2010
  • Number of Cigars Released: 195 Boxes of 25 Cigars (4,875 Total Cigars)

Looking at this cigar I can’t help but think this is one of the prettiest broadleaf wrappers I have seen from Tatuaje in a while. It has a beautiful dark brown color with a bit of a reddish tint to it. The color is very evenly spread across the wrapper with no splotches or anything. It’s almost too pretty to be a broadleaf wrapper. It has a seamless wrap with some veins here and there and it has a perfectly applied triple cap with a pigtail although it’s not exactly like the pork tenderloins pigtail, Its more of a cross between the Face cap and a normal pigtail meaning its a pigtail but not quite as fanned out as the pork tenderloins. The foot is also unfinished giving the cigar just a great overall look.

The Pre light aroma is full of leather, chocolate and an overall sweet tobacco note. The Pre light draw is full of cedar, chocolate, and a touch of pepper, overall a very nice rich earthy pre light.

Starting off in the First Third I am immediately hit with a massive amount of pepper and spice. It fills my mouth and my nasal cavity and tingles all the way down my throat. It’s a very intense spicy and peppery finish just washing all over my tongue. After a few minutes the cigar settles nicely and I start to get a load of flavors, wood, leather, chocolate, and a touch of cinnamon on the finish. At this point in the cigar the spice and pepper is just balanced so perfectly with the bold flavors I am getting. It’s a very well rounded cigar.

Tatuaje Barclay Rex 100th Anniversary 6.png

Coming into the Second Third the cigar shifts dramatically. It gets very sweet, the leather becomes very heavy and the cinnamon notes are washing in and out with every puff. There is a real creaminess to the finish and I am getting some coffee notes here and there. While I am experiencing all these flavors the pepper and spice is still there in perfect amounts just balancing everything out. The burn is perfect and the draw is producing massive amounts of smoke. So far its an absolute pleasure to smoke this cigar…

Tatuaje Barclay Rex 100th Anniversary 7.png

Finishing up in the Final Third the cigar is just moving along nicely. I am enjoying every minute of it. There is a ton of flavor and just the right amount of spice. The finish is long and at times I have to sit back and take a breather. This cigar is very strong and it hits me going into the final third but again it’s all about the balance, the large flavors and all the spice which balance out the strength and make it bearable. Leather, wood, coffee, cinnamon note, and a great sweet, salty combination make this cigar easy to nub.

Tatuaje Barclay Rex 100th Anniversary 8.png

Final Notes:

  • Pete Johnson has commented on the forums that this cigar is the “big brother to the pork tenderloin” I will say that its definitely stronger and more spicy than the Pork Tenderloin, but if I had to guess I would say the blend was tweaked a little because I found this to be much more flavorful and more balanced. Unless it’s just the vitola playing tricks on me or the broadleaf crop is different enough to make a difference…
  • The key to this cigars success is the flavor, complexity, balance and overall construction. To me it had the entire package and it excelled in all of those categories. It’s no surprise that this profile is right up my alley but I think this cigar is going to be loved by a lot of people.
  • Billy Rella and I were speaking on the phone and we both agreed that this cigar tastes like a New York pretzel, a perfect combination of full flavor, sweetness and a salty, spicy balance. How appropriate right?
  • Many times during the process of me smoking this cigar for the review I kept saying “this cigar reminds me of the SW Maduro!” It really did. Granted it is more powerful but flavor wise I found it to be very similar to the SW Maduro which is never a bad thing!
  • There are only 195 boxes of 25 made and I can tell you this much, I put another order in for a box. This is definitely a cigar I want to smoke a few years from now. It has so much strength and flavor that I think it will mellow out into something even more enjoyable, the perfect cigar to age so to speak.
  • The Barclay Rex 100th should be shipping out on Tuesday the 9th (for people who preordered)…as of 9:20am on the 9th, they have about 50 boxes left between all the stores (all three stores are selling them, so if one is sold out, call the other two)…
  • Final Smoking Time was right around 2 hours

 

The Bottom Line: If you are a fan of full bodied, full flavored, full strength cigars than this will a homerun for you. Even if you don’t like full strength cigars, I think this will be enjoyed by all because the flavors are there and are so in your face that it makes you forget about the strength or at least tolerate it. This cigar is what I have come to expect from Pete Johnson and his broadleaf creations. It certainly seems to be his go to type of blend and I for one understand and am glad because we could use more cigars like this on the market. Its all about the flavor and balance and this cigar has all of that and then some.

 

 

Final Score: 93

73 comments
Zen smoker222
Zen smoker222

So stoked to try it finally tracked one down

MattBell
MattBell

Wow. Thanks for a great review. The closed foot looks so good and the stick looks awesome overall.

Now I have to get some...

Aizuddin Danian
Aizuddin Danian

Fantastic review, the way you described it makes my mouth water!

Foe
Foe

I'm drooling...and envious...

tfb5701
tfb5701

Sounds like a great cigar. If it tastes like the SW maduro then I might have to pick a few up. Thanks for the review!

topher
topher

Sounds like a great cigar. Maybe a tat I'll actually like!

JoshK
JoshK

Normally these be a bit pricing for me, but I'm going to the Broad St. store to pick up a single just because of your review.

cucumber.breath
cucumber.breath

Nice review!!!!!!!! Can't wait to get my hands on one!

RoyS
RoyS

This cigar sounds great. I loved the pork tenderloin and this one sounds even better, can't wait to try it. If I can get my hands on some. Great pics by the way. Keep up the good work.

iltuono
iltuono

The Lexington store also has a lounge, until Bloomberg padlocks the joint! Looking fwd to getting a few of these.

Todd T.
Todd T.

Nice review, I love Tatuaje smokes.

Tim
Tim

wow awesome sounding smoke

stewshi
stewshi

great review never had the chance to smoke a SW Maduro but only have heard great things

axi
axi

sweet review steve. it looks like i gotta pick up a few

alpha8a
alpha8a

hoping to be able to find a fiver of these

Frank
Frank

WOW...it sounds like a great cigar...thanks for the review!!!

mrjerry420
mrjerry420

I'm a big fall of all Pete's smokes. This one sounds amazing!!!

Cateacher
Cateacher

Sounds like a great stick Steve! Anything mentioned in the same breathe as the SW Maduro makes me smile. Great review and thanks for sharing.

Tony (issues)
Tony (issues)

Great review Brooks!

I'm not going to be able to put an order in on this one but it sounds like a stick I would love!

JamesTF
JamesTF

Looks fantastic! Would love to try one!

Landon
Landon

Another awesome review Brooks. Any idea when these will land?

njstone
njstone

Great review, Steve! This sounds awesome. I just wish it was a bit smaller and carried the same strong flavors. I think Pete should really make a regular line out of a cigar like this!.

Jacob
Jacob

I kind of like the new look of the bands. They're not the greatest I've ever seen, but I appreciate the simplicity of them. This smoke sounds truly fantastic. I'm going to see if I can still track some down and abuse my budget a little bit more.

JwyAtt55
JwyAtt55

You had me at Sw maduro!! Can not wait to try these now!

Aaron U
Aaron U

I don't know if I've even been as excited about a tat cigar before. I hope to get my hands on one somehow.

Badmotorshayman
Badmotorshayman

Fantastic review, as I cannot wait for these to ship. When are they available?

hawgmauler
hawgmauler

I'm a big fan of Pete and Tatuaje cigars. I wish all of his sticks were available as regular production. It's a shame these exclusive sticks aren't widely available and have a limited production. I wish I had the money and space to stock up on all his stuff. Guess who's buying a lottery ticket. :)

Logan
Logan

sounds like a great cigar!

J.A.S.
J.A.S.

With so many cigars being launched in the last few months (and what is pending) I cannot decide about going for a box or not; hope to get one sample first! Great review Steve!

Austin_Smoker
Austin_Smoker

It sounds incredible (as all of Pete's sticks do); however, they all seem to have the same blends lately. I guess it stands, "don't fix it if it ain't broke!"

I'd love to have one in the humidor!!

themoneycollector
themoneycollector

I'm not a fan of the bands, but as long as the smoke is good, that's what really matters

pr0nphisher
pr0nphisher

great review, now to find some and obliterate my cigar budget.

Badfish
Badfish

Wow, that review made me want to try one, and soon! Good luck with the killer website Brooks!

Cheers,

Badfish

Justin
Justin

Thanks for being the first person to review this stick!

Guy
Guy

Great review Steve, I'm in, I love what Pete does.

Guy ,
France

Scott
Scott

that cigar looks great

PJ
PJ

Great description of a great looking cigar. Xtra points for the home made looking band.

jake79
jake79

Love the shape and the head of this cigar. Looks to be tapered to the foot. Great review.

SignalHill323
SignalHill323

Very nice review Lilo. Glad I got myself a box!

David M
David M

I'm not big fan of spicy sticks, but I sure would like to try this one!

James
James

Sounds like an excellent cigar, might have to see if I can pick one up when I go to NYC.

PeteRI
PeteRI

Glad I put in my order last week. Sounds like a winner...great review!

Keith1911
Keith1911

Sounds like a great stick! A agree with you, the band looks a little discombobulated.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] is the TAA (bottom) compared to the Barclay Rex (middle) and the Pork Tenderloin [...]