Review: Tatuaje “The Frank”


In 2008 Pete Johnson of Tatuaje fame, with the help of a good friend, came up with the idea for a very special Halloween cigar release. Pete decided that each year around October 31st he would release a cigar based on a classic monster of his choosing. For the first release, dubbed “The Frank” (after Frankenstein, obviously) the top 100 retailers who sold Tatuaje cigars would be entered into a lottery, and only 13 “Unlucky” retailers were chosen to sell equal numbers of the 666 boxes that were produced (announced on Oct. 13th, of course). Each box included 13 cigars placed in their own “blood spattered” cedar coffin. They looked like this:

Tatuaje

Each box was individually numbered as well (out of 666).

Tatuaje

One year after the release of the “Frank”, Tatuaje released another cigar, dubbed the “Boris”…this was a cigar that was part of the “Actor’s Series” that was supposed to memorize the actors who played the role of the monsters in each year’s release (Thus, Boris Karloff, who played Frankenstein), However, as far as we know, this idea has been scrapped for future Monster releases.

This past Halloween we saw the release of the Second Installment of the “Monster Series”, “The Drac” named after Dracula. However, because of consumer backlash Pete Johnson decided to release 1,300 coffins instead of 666 so more people could get them. This would be the first time that would happen, with the future releases consisting of 666 coffin boxes and an additional 1,300 plain 10 count boxes (for people who didn’t care about the collectors box).

Pete is on record as saying that next year’s release (2011) will be The Face, (after “LeatherFace“), a 5 ½ x 58ish stick “with a gnarly, ugly wrapper on it, a marbleized cover leaf. The cigar will be unfinished, with the wrapper drooping off the cigar”. The Wolfman is rumored for the year after that (2012).

Here we go…

Tatuaje

  • Cigar Reviewed: Tatuaje “The Frank”
  • Country of Origin: Nicaragua
  • Factory: Tabacalera Cubanas S.A.
  • Wrapper: Connecticut Broadleaf
  • Binder: Nicaragua
  • Filler: Nicaragua
  • Size: 7 5/8 inches
  • Ring Gauge: 49
  • Vitola: Box pressed Double Corona
  • Est. Price: MSRP $13 (I paid $30 per cigar)
  • Date Released: October 13, 2008
  • Number of Cigars Released: 666 Boxes of 13 (8,658 total cigars)
  • Number of Cigars Smoked for Review: 2

The Tatuaje “Frank” is a pleasure to look at. It sports a beautiful dark chocolate colored broadleaf wrapper with a few veins running up and down the length of the cigar. It’s a bit toothy and has a nice oily look to it. Connecticut Broadleaf has never been the prettiest wrapper, but personally I think its imperfections give it its beauty. It doesn’t have a strong aroma at all. I get a faint tobacco aroma and I get just a bit of cedar and chocolate on the pre-light draw.

The cigar’s First Third starts off very mellow in my opinion. It’s definitely on the lower end of medium body for me. I get a nice aged cedar flavor as well as a tiny bit of leather. There is a little bit of spice but not as much as you would expect. It’s a very mild start so far. The ash doesn’t hold long at all. It falls off after just after an inch or so. The draw and burn are perfect.

Tatuaje

The Second Third is picking up nicely. The cedar is still present as well as the leather but now I am getting a nice roasted nut flavor. The cigar has also taken on more of a creamy profile, especially on the finish. The spice has all but died. The cigar is a solid medium body at this point.

Tatuaje

The Final Third is easily my favorite part of the cigar. The broadleaf wrapper is starting to show more of the flavor it’s known for and the cigar has taken on a deeper, richer flavor profile. The cedar has turned to a nice oak flavor and the leather has increases considerably. I also get a nice roasted coffee bean flavor as well as a pleasant, sweet nuttiness with a hint of chocolate. It’s nice and creamy through the nose but the spice has yet to show its face again.

Tatuaje

 

Final Notes:

  • This cigar started off much more mild than I anticipated! I also was expecting a little more spice but it just wasn’t to be. If you are looking for that “Pepin spice” you won’t find it here.
  • I really enjoyed the aged cedar in the beginning but it just wasn’t enough for my palette. I was left wanting more. However, The cigar picked up significantly at the end and showed rich creamy coffee and leather flavors that I have grown to love in broadleaf wrapped cigars. It was bitter sweet because up until then I was pretty much bored with the cigar.
  • The final 3rd was the star of the show. Without it I would be giving this a much lower score.
  • The Burn, draw and overall construction were absolutely perfect. I didn’t need to touch it up once.
  • The Final Smoking time was 1 hour 49 minutes.

The Bottom Line: I have heard from a few people who smoked this cigar that when it came out it was easily a 96-98 point cigar. I enjoyed this cigar but I just can’t put it in that category. My feelings are that this cigar lost a little something in the 2 years it’s been aging and with the exception of the final third the flavors were just very average. Is this a good cigar?? YES. Would I smoke another? YES. Will I track these down and spend $40 a piece for them? NO. In my opinion underneath the Frank band is just a regular Tatuaje cigar with above average flavors. It’s Better than most, but just not good enough to warrant a 95 or up.

 

Final Score: 92

79 comments
curt
curt

Sweet concept

Paul
Paul

Good review - heard about from another website. Trying to find but having no luck.

DG
DG

Nice review. I'm searching for one of these everywhere!

bcannon87
bcannon87

I think I want this to be mine!! Sounds Lick a great cigar!!! I would love to try it!!

quo155
quo155

Great review!

I can not wait until I can get my hand on one of these to try!

Long ashes to ya!

TriMarkC
TriMarkC

Sorry, forgot to add my contact info in my 1st comment ... JUST in case you need to email me that I won! :-)

TriMarkC
TriMarkC

I haven't seen any of the Monster Series in the wild, but I've been scouting for them ever since I've heard.

So here's hoping against the odds that I can actually win one!!!

Fantastic review, as well! Fair and honest. Nice job!

Joe
Joe

Nice review Lilo. I've got two of these sitting, but haven't tried one yet. Looking forward to it when I have the time.

Mayor
Mayor

Thanks for the review. Look forward to more from you.

nick dimarco
nick dimarco

Way to make us all jealous! Nice review as always, hopefully I can find one still!

Ryan-c
Ryan-c

Still haven't seen one of these in the wild, but this seems like a great smoke. I wonder if te age really adversely impacted the flavor or if you just got a dud (even though it was still good). Nice pics, BTW.

Goldie
Goldie

You are crazy for giving one of these away, but I like your style.

Cuban Pete
Cuban Pete

Great review. You think they are getting milder with age?

John F
John F

NIce review Lilo! Look forward to your reviews!

Brooks Whittington
Brooks Whittington

Frank,

Lilo will be doing all of the photography for his reviews (one of the reasons he is perfect for the job), unless there is something he cannot shoot (ie, box photos he does not have etc)...

Frank
Frank

Lilo, congratulations on your first review. I think Brooks picked a very capable candidate that definitely won't disappoint the faithful follower of this great website. Just a quick question...do you do your own photography on the reviews? I definitely enjoys Brooks photography and was pleasantly surprised with the pictures of the Tatuaje Frank review.
Keep up the good work.

thechenman
thechenman

Enjoyed reading your review Lilo...wish you much success here.

Smith
Smith

I thought the next one was going to be Leatherface?

PaulV
PaulV

I was meaning to say what Wolfman looks like..

PaulV
PaulV

Great review

He is basically going through the show "The Munsters". It will be interesting to see what the Drac looks like. This years release sounds like it will be one ugly looking stick, hopefully it smoked amazing though.

Cheers,
Paul

Jacob B
Jacob B

So schwwwweeet.

Nice first review here.

Jacob

Robert
Robert

Thanks for the review!

Dbell
Dbell

Best of the monster series?

dj
dj

Oh. My.

Oh. My.

Crazy? Yes!

AlohaStyle
AlohaStyle

Good job on the first review Lilo! Keep up the good work and Brooks' site won't miss a beat. :)

t_ron99
t_ron99

Welcome aboard Lilo!

You're off to a great start on this site for sure. Thanks for helping out on this site. You are upholding the high standards for a comprehensive review with top notch pics. That's exactly what keeps me coming back to this site....and that fact that Brooks has some of the finest cigars on the market reviewed on his site. I imagine that if he was posting pics of white owls and Swisher Sweets I would lose interest.

Logan
Logan

great job on the first post! mmmmmm. yum Franks!

Mike D.
Mike D.

Sounds like a great smoke.

pfm721
pfm721

Lilo welcome! Look forward to seeing more of your reviews. Brooks and I have done some trades in the past if your are ever looking for something let me know and I will see if I have it.

greg
greg

never seen one of these in real life, nice review!!

Kris
Kris

I think this cigar might be the hardest Tatuaje just yet!

Foe
Foe

Seamless review! Good to know it's not worth the high after-market price, unless you're a collector anyway. But yes, you guys are a little nuts giving away a $40+ stick, LOL.

ama
ama

Great first post LiLo! I really hope I win this one! I've always wanted to try this stick but have never had the chance.

nic olson
nic olson

great first review lilo, way to come out running with the frank!

HabanoHam
HabanoHam

Nice Review Lilo! Welcome aboard, You take damn good snaps of the smokes too.

LiLo
LiLo

I should clarify again that i think this is a wonderful cigar. I just feel that the frank mystique has propelled it to where people expect it to be a 100 point cigar. It just isn't the case in my opinion. It's still a VERY good cigar in its own right though!

TheGentleman
TheGentleman

Thanks for a great review. I wasn't fortunate enough to get any Franks, but I have had several Boris'. Those have been fantastic! My favorite wrapper is a Conn. BL so I'd love to try one of these.

Soundwave13
Soundwave13

Nicely done Steve! It's interesting that this has mellowed out so dramatically, but I still love the combination of the brown label filler & the broadleaf maduro wrapper!

tooomanycolors
tooomanycolors

Hey Lilo if you dont like em enough give it back! Nice review for your first one here, I think Brooks made a good decision letting you "help" him here.

Guy
Guy

Great review Lilo, great Photos also.
Yes, well as for the " Frank ", I guess I should smoke mine now because, as
it seems, they don't age well, like many NC's that I've exprienced.

Guy,
France

Yiorgos
Yiorgos

Nice review LiLo, you're off to a good start!

Cateacher
Cateacher

Great first review Lilo! Been trying to get my hands on one of these and it sounds like I better do it in a hurry before they lose all their flavor.

pTr939
pTr939

Great 1st review Steve!

Had another Frank not too long ago and they were just as good as the first few times. I definitely agree with the 90s score.

Cyrann
Cyrann

Good work Lilo. Nice Review.

Doctorossi
Doctorossi

Are Franks really going for $40 somewhere? Seems like it wouldn't be too expensive to re-roll a Tainos with a broadleaf wrapper. :)

CPStaley
CPStaley

Wow...Actually giving one away? You guys are CRAZY! But I'll enter anyways!

Jwyatt55
Jwyatt55

LILO great review! I had the pleasure of smoking a frank last October in Dallas at a Tatuaje event (thanks to Brooks!). Was an incredible smoke but the experience was even better because of the fellow botls that I enjoyed it with. Completely agree that the final third is where this bad boy really shines.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] the only mention of a release date has been June.You can read our reviews of the Monster Series:Tatuaje “The Frank”Tatuaje “The Drac”Tatuaje “The Face”Tatuaje “The Wolfman” [...]

  2. [...] Tatuaje The Frank (7 5/8 x 49) — October 2008 [...]

  3. [...] Tatuaje The Frank (7 5/8 x 49) — October 2008 [...]

  4. [...] Tatuaje The Frank (7 5/8 x 49) — October 2008 [...]

  5. [...] Tatuaje The Frank (7 5/8 x 49) — October 2008 [...]

  6. [...] Tatuaje The Frank (7 5/8 x 49) — 2008 — Named after the Frankenstein — 666 Dress Boxes of 13 Cigars (8,658 Total Cigars) [...]

  7. [...] 2008, Pete Johnson announced his first Monster Series release, The Frank, named after the movie monster of the 1931 classic film. After the fanfare that release attracted, [...]