Ten Questions for 2011


Screw top ten lists… Okay, maybe not. My list will be out at some point for all four of you that care, but in the mean time, the important one. Without a doubt, 2010 has been an interesting time for cigars and 2011 has the potential to be even more interesting.

Disclaimers: These aren’t in any order of importance, rather I just started making a list. I know stuff that I shouldn’t know, none of that is below. Things told in confidence or off the record are off the record. Those things aren’t in any part of what’s below, as I would rather not say then intentionally mislead you. What is below is more observation or simple math, either that or it’s just random things that I find important that no one could care about. — el niño diablo.

NewImage

1. (No) More Brands
It may be the best time to be a consumer, but it’s one of the worst to be a retailer. There are seemingly an endless amount of brands and lines popping up every week. Most everyone agrees that it’s not like the boom in the sense that the quality of cigars is incredibly high. That all being said, it’s definitely getting harder to get some tobaccos… cough, cough broadleaf. Will the bubble finally burst? It seems unlikely that the world can honestly support that many more cigars.

2.png

2. General Success
Sure, everyone is still upset with how the CAO merger went, but that story has been mistold a million times. What’s missed in all of the 2010 General Cigar Co. news is what’s happened with La Gloria Cubana. Only months after Ernesto Perez-Carrillo was able to leave after his non-compete and contract, General has placed tons of energy in LGC. While the cigars aren’t being made at El Credito in Miami, there is some boutique feel to the new releases. As for the CAO front, General assumed all current CAO contracts, so at least for the time being, the cigars aren’t going to change (People forget that CAO didn’t make their own cigars.) Will brands disappear, you’d have to imagine.

3.png

3. Miami Cigar & Co.
Nestor’s company is changing. The recent press release regarding Rene Castaneda’s new job even hinted at the big changes coming. La Aurora and Miami Cigar & Co. are in the process of integrating better, with the main goal being efficiency, translating to lower prices for consumers. Things are still being finalized, but I would doubt if this is the only change for MCC in 2011.

NewImage

4. Nicaragua for Sale?
Rumors regarding Davidoff Courting Perdomo and Altadis (and General) looking at Drew Estate have run rampant for months, even if no one has said anything publicly. Both sales seem off for a lot of reasons, but given Davidoff’s purchase of Camacho, they want both a Nicaraguan brand and the ability to compete with Altadis and General in some regards. If Altadis is looking at more than just Drew Estate, this could mean a lot of changes in a year following consolidation at Davidoff (Camacho & Cusano) and the parents of General Cigar Co. and CAO.

NewImage

5. The Free Agents
Jon Huber, formerly of CAO; Tim Ozgener, formerly of CAO; Sam Leccia, formerly of Oliva/Cain/NUb; Mike Chiusano? The list goes on… There’s always the Huber to Tatuaje rumor, which is where I’d put my money. No one has heard much rumblings from Sam, but it’s only a matter of time. Tim owns a bar and has said that he wants to focus on that for the time being. Given the state of the cigar industry (see numero uño), it might be smart to not bring yet another brand to the market in 2011. However, the former CAO headquarters, with the Escaparte, is still owned by the family and its unlikely they’d be able to sell that without losing money, as there are no other cigar companies that would seeminly take over the Nasheville space. Non-competes are what’s really going to be a big factor and I’d expect that a few of them have one.

20106.png

6. Pepín, The Energizer Bunny
At some point, Pepín is going to have to slow down. One ten day stretch this past year included a few events in Chicago, flying to Tokyo for five or so days and then rushing back to Arizona for the opening of the first My Father Cigar Lounge. He just celebrated his 60th birthday and I haven’t even began to talk about the blends. He’s still making all of United Tobacco/EO Brands stuff, responsible for more of Holt’s/Ashton’s blends, Nestor Miranda, Tatuaje and his own stuff, and then some. At some point, the travel and workload has to decrease, or at least that’s if I had to take some guesses. Even if Pepín doesn’t slow down, he is still the superstar in the business with two factories and two of the most popular companies under his wing.

20107.png

7. The Rise of A.J. and Jesus Fuego
A.J. Fernandez has long been responsible for other people’s stuff: Diesel, Man O’ War, some Rocky, one of Sol Cubanos and Brickhouse; but now he’s going out on his own. With San Lotano and Jesus Fuego’s reinvention, the two are becoming a larger part of the national B&M market and when you add one, you usually got to take away another. I still think the Ruination is the best A.J. blend to date, and that’s restricted to Cigars International, but without a doubt the two of them have big plans for 2011 and with point number one, you have to wonder which other brand will be affected.

20108.png

8. Legislation

 

Smoking bans, the FDA, taxes… you know the drill. It’s always going to be on this list, and with good reason.

9. Studio Tobac

 

Outside of the Serie V Maduro, Oliva hasn’t introduced a new cigar since the Connecticut Reserve. In addition to the departure of Sam Leccia, Studio Tobac promises to bring new sizes and more of a Skunk Works like feel to Oliva. The Cain F NUb hits stores in January, the Cain Daytona comes a few months later and the Cain F Lancero will be available on the Studio Tobac tour in February. What else will be added? Who knows.

201010.png

10. The IPCPR Show
It returns to Vegas, which is a good thing, I think. Still, the problems I wrote about in August aren’t going to be solved by simply doing nothing. What seems to be the largest issue discussed is that of the bloggers and new media, which might as well be the last thing that needs conversation. I’m going to make this blunt: unless they get rid of the pre-show specials, the show is done in a few years, end of story.

6 comments
Claude Dunlap
Claude Dunlap

Hi friend. I ‘m still quite noob at blog and the entire things about this field. There are lods of jargons I still can’t understand. I’m not pretty sure I will be able to write half decent to yours. I am gonna read the whole site perhaps I will be able to grasp your writing style a little.

Charlie
Charlie

Marco,

You won't have to wait long my friend...

Charlie

Marco
Marco

There are more like me that don't post often but we are looking forward to all the Top Cigars lists that come out this time of the year.
Be happy to see yours and those from the various bloggers doing their thing, various biases in all their glory... Ain't it fun!

RE: Mr. Perez-Carrillo, I love what he and his family have done with their company. The cigars are first rate. LGC did intrigue me with the light/dark wrapper experiment and they weren't bad, but otherwise I don't care for their products these days.

Charlie
Charlie

David,

As for the LGC and CAO comparison, the one big difference is that CAO doesn't make their own cigars. I think the La Traviata and Brazilia would be the last cigars to change.

Charlie

dmjones1009
dmjones1009

Interesting read, Charlie. I guess I'm one of the 3..sorry, 4...that care about what you say about your top 10 stogies of the year, but I also have a few words to say about some of what you posited here:

2. Regarding General's stewardship of La Gloria Cubana: you seem very chipper about what Team La Gloria has done since Ernie left. I guess I just cannot feel very positive about it. Even 4 or 5 years ago LGC had some sticks I really enjoyed, but I cannot be overly enthusiastic about anything they have produced since Ernie's departure. The 2 new ones this year were middling to good smokes, but definitely nothing to get excited about. Will General be good stewards for CAO? I hope so. I already know that quite a few stores are planning on discontinuing or not re-ordering product once stock is depleted. I have boxes of LT Animados and LT Maduros put aside for remembering "the good old days."

5. Yes, lots of free agents out there right now looking for new opportunities. Some of those may not turn out quite as your or I have expected, but time will tell.

6. I have theorized that DPG is not really a man, but actually a Cuban blending robot that escaped from Havana. How else to explain the seemingly endless number of blends and variations on them that he is about to create for so many different customers? How long before he is forced to sign a non-compete with himself?

10. The show seems to be more about relationship-building at this point than anything else. You have a good point: if there are not more show-exclusive deals, the retailers will stop spending the time and money to go. Some already have.

Matthew
Matthew

Excellent article Charlie - great read

Trackbacks

  1. [...] as was alluded to in my Ten Questions for 2011 article, the times are changing. Altadis made a huge (but perhaps failed) effort at the show to introduce [...]

  2. [...] is the newest cigar from Jesus Fuego, a wonderful cigarmaker in his own right and someone I have previously dubbed as one of two up and comers who seem like they are here more than just to stay. And if [...]

  3. [...] year, I published an article entitled Ten Questions for 2011. The concept was simple, what were a few of the topics to watch for in the upcoming year. With the [...]

  4. [...] Friday, December 30, 2011 · Leave a Comment Last year, I published an article entitled Ten Questions for 2011. The concept was simple, what were a few of the topics to watch for in the upcoming year. With the [...]