Review: La Grand Classe


There wasn’t a ton of fanfare for the release of Dion Giolito’s latest cigar, La Grand Classe, when it came out in late November. A Tweet from FUMARE was sent out the morning it became available, and as of this writing it has yet to be mentioned on the Illusione Twitter account since being released on November 27. The cigar is a store exclusive for FUMARE, the store that Giolito owns in Reno, NV.

The project has been mentioned on the FUMARE website since at least November 2011, and seemed to be slated for release in July 2012 before being pushed back to November. Giolito had kept details about La Grand Classe to an absolute minimum prior to its release, including how it would be distributed and reasons for its delay. He did hand out unbanded cigars at Charmed Leaf’s August 2012 boutique cigar party during the IPCPR convention and trade show, hinting that they could be possible prototypes.

Another aspect about this project that has seemingly been in flux is the name. It’s been referenced with several spellings, and the box that the cigars come in uses two different spellings: the main sticker says La Grand Classe while the secondary sticker says La Grande Classe. There was a point when this was referred to as Le Grand Classe, at least via previous logos, and currently the FUMARE site also makes reference to Le Grande Classe.

The name translates to roughly ‘The Great Class’ from several languages, including French, Italian, Latin and Spanish. There is also usage of the phrase pauca sed bona in the artwork, which Google Translate returns as small but good in Latin. The phrase has also been added to the tax stamp, replacing the word Nicaragua that had been shown on a previous version.

From FUMARE’s website:

“Many unique tobaccos can be sourced. Some yields can produce cigars in the millions, whereas some of the most desirous, exquisite and flavorful tobaccos sourced can only produce just a handful of cigars.” - Dion Giolito — illusione cigars

Introducing ‘La Grande Classe.’

Like many rareities in gem market, so is La Grande Classe Cigars – an exclusive of F U M A R E . Each batch of exquisite cigars will be a limited run of sizes and blends created by lauded blender Dion Giolito. All tobaccos will be personally chosen from the finest fields in Nicaragua, graded and aged for superior performance.

La Grande Classe gives the client unprecedented access to a true small-batch run of cigars made with superior grade tobaccos in both unique sizes, and different flavor profiles. Le Grande Classe is an extremely rare product at the highest caliber of performance, flavor and construction.

 

_______________________________________________________________________

La Grand Classe comes in one of the most dressed down forms of packaging to date. There’s a simple cardboard box with a tax stamp that contains 25 unbanded cigars in cellophane that are labeled, “La Grande Classe.” Here’s what the box looks like:

La Grand Classe Box 1

La Grand Classe Box 2

La Grand Classe Box 3

_______________________________________________________________________


Now that we’ve got that out of the way, let’s light this stick up.

La Grand Classe 1

  • Cigar Reviewed: La Grand Classe
  • Country of Origin: Nicaragua
  • Factory: Tabacos Valle de Jalapa S.A.
  • Wrapper: Mexican San Andrés Maduro
  • Binder: Nicaragua
  • Filler: Nicaragua
  • Size: 5 1/2 Inches
  • Ring Gauge: 52
  • Vitola: Gordito
  • MSRP: $5.99 (Boxes of 25, $149.75)
  • Date Released: November 27, 2012 
  • Number of Cigars Released: 470 Boxes of 25 Cigars (11,750 Total Cigars)
  • Number of Cigars Smoked For Review: 3

The color of the La Grand Classe’s wrapper is the first thing that caught my attention as it seems to have an almost grayish tint to it. Its dry, rough textured leaves have a few small veins—visible but not distracting—and the cigar is borderline hard when squeezed. The foot is floral and fragrant, sometimes smelling more like a fresh fruit salad and other times leaning more towards flowers, though both come with a fair amount of pepper. The cold draw is spot-on with the air moving well through what feels like a well-packed cigar and carrying a slightly sweet note reminiscent of yellow apples, a bit of pear, some white toast and just a sprinkling of pepper.

 

_______________________________________________________________________

 

The La Grand Classe gets off to a quick start as the first third has plenty of earth, spice and eye-watering pepper in the first puffs that evolve into notes of brown sugar and baking spices that hit the nose more than the palate. A good amount of blue-grey smoke comes off the cigar as the flavor finds its balance and becomes a bit more Illusione-like in the first inch. An earthy flavor sets in as the burn line gets to an inch, and it’s apparent the flavor is fading fast. The earthy note gives way to a lighter wood note as the transition to the second third seems to begin.

La Grand Classe 2

There is a decided mellowing of the flavors by the time the cigar gets into the second third, with an almost marshmallow like flavor coming out in one cigar. The intensity of the flavors has died down significantly, particularly when compared to the first few puffs, as the earthy taste is a thing of the past, and even the wood note has faded largely into the background. It’s not until just past the midpoint that notes of pepper and earth start to come back, just as it seems like the La Grand Classe was turning into an almost mild cigar.

La Grand Classe 3

The final third brings a gradual increase in flavor, though at times it gets a bit gritty as the levels of earth build back up. In the first cigar smoked, there is a sharp metallic taste that comes out of nowhere with about three inches to go, though it fades quickly and is replaced by a strong, peppery closing note, bringing the La Grand Classe almost full circle from where it started.

La Grand Classe 4

_______________________________________________________________________

 

  • The more I smoke Mexican San Andrés Maduro wrappers, the less I think I like them. From both a taste and a texture perspective, they just don’t seem to resonate with me. I’m still a fan of the natural version, though.
  • All three cigars I smoked felt like they needed some humidity. Between the roughness of the leaf and what I’m assuming is a good amount of tobacco in them, they felt downright hard.
  • Much like Pete Johnson’s new L’Atelier Imports and his more established Tatuaje/Havana Cellars, Giolito seems to want to keep La Grand Classe and Illusione different. While the tax stamp no longer says “Illusione” on it and Giolito doesn’t go as so far as using the “from the makers of…” mantra, it’s going to be an uphill battle.
  • The first cigar I smoked for this review had a chip in the wrapper, which became the starting point for a small split. Another split occurred at the end of the same cigar, just after the metallic note hit.
  • This is the second release—albeit third cigar—of Giolito’s from the Eduardo Fernández/Paul Palmer Tabacos Valle de Jalapa S.A. (TABSA) factory. The first was the 2011/2012 Singularé.
  • I’ve been a fan of Illusione’s packaging, both from a design aesthetic and that it fits nicely on retailers’ shelves. The La Grande Classe packaging leaves a bit to be desired in the fact that it’s a cardboard box with stickers on it, but then again, Giolito was only making them for his store. It does continue his trend of tightly-packed boxes that take up minimal space on a store shelf.
  • There didn’t seem to be any extra room in the box, as the cigars were packed in as tightly as they could be and the box was bowing a bit.
  • The notes on La Grand Classe mention two beverage pairings: Bruichladdich Organic whisky and Dogfish Head 90 Minute IPA.
  • In a time where blend information seems harder to come by, FUMARE went so far as to list the Aganorsa farms that the tobacco for La Grand Classe comes from: Chilamate, San Nicolas and Buenos Aires.
  • I love single-vitola releases, by the way, so this gets a big thumbs up.
  • I’m not sure what to make of the different spellings of this project. The main sticker has La Grand Classe while the secondary red sticker that is also on the box and on each cigar has La Grande Classe.
  • Speaking of spelling, FUMARE seems to prefer its name be spelled not just in capitals but with spaces between each letter, as in F U M A R E.
  • Final smoking time is about two hours and 10 minutes.

 

_______________________________________________________________________

The Bottom Line: There’s an understandable desire to compare La Grand Classe to other Illusione products, given that it’s made by Giolito and sold only at his store. However, as mentioned before there is no indication on the box or the cigar that this has any connection to Illusione, absent Giolito himself, and he has stated this is not an Illusione product. The flavor progression was a little off for me, beginning with the pepper punch that kicks off the cigar and leads you to think it’s going to be some absolute pepper bomb before beginning a steady decline in strength and flavor that bottoms out near the midway point, only to start a steady rebuilding of flavor and strength in the final third. There also isn’t a ton of variance in the flavors, mainly earth, wood and spice the whole way through in varying intensities. For me, Giolito left a big part of the cigar canvas unused, as the middle third could have been used to show something in terms of flavor. However, it bears mentioning that this is a $6 cigar, a price point not generally known for being ripe with flavor-packed cigars. So when all this is taken into consideration, what are you left with? A very good store exclusive made by a solid company at a reasonable price point that is worth trying, but not hunting down.

Final Score: 86

20 comments
Scroni
Scroni

Idk, I like them.  Definitely not what I was expecting (considering where they were coming from), but pretty good non-the-less (the couple that I have tried did not seem dry, they almost had a soft type of sandy/velvety texture to them which I found very interesting).  I could really care less about the box, but a simple cigar band of sorts could have been nice (again though, I don't really care).  I'm glad I picked up a box.  I'm interested to see if they change any over the coming months.

mnwill
mnwill

I do agree they seemed a little on the dry side but I thought it was a good smoke.

njp70to70cigars
njp70to70cigars

I am always amazed at reviews posted on this site, and not in a good way.  Price and packaging being in the conversation is bad news.  I work in the business and strongly disagree about the statement about $6 cigars not being known for flavor.  The La Reloba brand out the My Father Factory is great example, the La Aroma de Cuba line is a great smoke, the Padron 2000, the Mooch Maduro line which comes in bundles is fantastic and so is the Clasico Corona Gorda, both made by Berger and Argenti. 

njp70to70cigars
njp70to70cigars

My point is, never let price or packaging reflect on the smoke, the Casa Magna colorado was number one cigar of the year in Cigar Aficionado in 2008, beating a Padron that was like 5x more in price. 

PHXCigarGuy
PHXCigarGuy

@njp70to70cigars To echo's Brooks' reply, price or packaging don't play a role in our reviews, other than being mentioned for sake of discussion and dialogue. Casa Magna was a game-changing cigar when it came out, and was followed up by another $5-6 cigar, CAO's La Traviata, that was the buzz of the 2010 trade show when it was released. Again, if you look on the whole spectrum of premium cigars, that price point isn't loaded with cigars with big flavors, but yes, there are some and some darn good ones at that.

I don't understand why you think price and packaging being in the conversation are bad news - both play a role in the consumer's mind. Unless you have an unlimited budget to spend on cigars, price will be an issue. As for packaging, every manufacturer has a different approach to it, each trying to figure out a way to make their products stand out in a humidor loaded with cigars. They don't reflect on our reviews, other than simply being part of the conversation.

njp70to70cigars
njp70to70cigars

@Brooks @njp70to70cigars @Charlie Minato @PHXCigarGuy I was just kidding dude, you guys are the ones who rated it, not me.  Those things aren't even meant to be smoked, it's not actually the same tobacco in a regular My Father, it's just to show the craftsman ship and the art of rolling, yet someone on this site smoke and rated on, they even rated the My Father pipe cigar.  Too funny

Brooks
Brooks moderator

@njp70to70cigars @PHXCigarGuy What makes us experts is the time we have put into smoking, finding and studying cigars and tobacco. Having said that, you can read the "About our reviews" section, where it says in part:

"We have never, and will never, state that our reviews are the end all, be all authority on cigars. In fact, from the formation of this blog, we have contended that reviews—by their very nature—are only one person’s opinion on their own experience. Cigars are subjective; reviews and scoring are even more subjective. We have a uniform process that all of halfwheel uses to produce, formulate and publish reviews—but ultimately, the rest is subjective."

And that really is all that needs to be said.

Charlie Minato
Charlie Minato moderator

@njp70to70cigars @PHXCigarGuy I responded to your comment about the Friends and Family in that review. I'm not sure we've ever marketed this site as "experts reviewing cigars' or "scientific cigar reviews." 

The idea that we created halfwheel so that we could make money off advertising is asinine. This site—and the four separate cigar blogs we each ran before this—were started because we enjoyed doing it. And if it ever got to a point where we stopped enjoying it individually, I imagine each one of us would stop doing it given the time commitment. The amount of time each one of us puts into this versus what we are monetarily compensated is a laughable excuse for being "paid." And I think that's the case with most cigar blogs.

We evaluate a pretty narrow niche—something I think no one else does—and I would imagine there are few individuals that smoke as many cigars in this niche as the four of us do on annual basis.

As for the specifics of our reviews, how we get to numbers, what we do, etc. We cover a lot of that here: http://halfwhee.ly/NyccRM

Reviewing is a subjective process at its core. We have fundamentals for how we go about doing things, but ultimately, as is mentioned numerous times throughout, it's a personal thing, for us, Stogie Review, other blogs, CA—everyone. At halfwheel, we do think we do a pretty good job about being up front about how we go about the process.

njp70to70cigars
njp70to70cigars

@PHXCigarGuy @njp70to70cigars  I guess I must have misread the part where it says " a price point not generally known for being ripe with flavor packed cigars".  It's a good point about CA magazine, it goes back onto you.  What made you guys experts on rating cigars? What are your qualifications to be able to rate cigars.  I'm pretty sure you're doing it for the same reason they are, to get people looking so you can sell space I guess.  Correct me if I am wrong.

Brooks
Brooks moderator like.author.displayName 1 Like

@njp70to70cigars First, in our reviews, neither price nor packaging have ANY impact on the final score, but it is important enough to be mentioned. Second, Patrick did say "not generally known", i.e., there will be exceptions. However, from your list, the Mooch Maduro line is not one of them, IMHO. Third, I can assure you that just because CA names a cigar Cigar of the Year does not inherently make it better then any other cigar.

CigrGy
CigrGy

These look pretty low end. The packaging quality conflicts with the naming on all levels. Pricing seems like an issue based on this review.

djshalifoe
djshalifoe like.author.displayName 1 Like

I was ready to pull the plastic trigger on these until I found out about the packaging...not very classy, in my opinion...

maxx
maxx like.author.displayName 1 Like

@djshalifoe How much more would you be willing to pay for fancier packaging?

djshalifoe
djshalifoe

@maxx @djshalifoe 

Just enough to enable it to happen, obviously...a slide-top wooden presentation adds ~$5 to the cost of each box, or so I've been told...

PHXCigarGuy
PHXCigarGuy

@djshalifoe @maxx The packaging isn't a draw back to me - sure it won't be something you're likely going to save or mount on your wall as a display piece, but how many of those are there? If anything, the simpler packaging makes it a more appealing cigar because it keeps the cost a bit lower.

thejavaman
thejavaman

I'm happy with this cigar.  Nice review.